• About
    • About HFA
    • HFA Awards
    • Associated Equipment
    • Banners on HFA
    • HFA Analytics Data
    • HFA Audio Setup History
    • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
    • Sitemap
    • Contact
  • HFA Awards
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Amplifier
      • All Amplifier Reviews
      • Integrated Amplifier
      • Preamplifier
      • Power Amplifier
      • Phono Preamp
    • Loudspeaker
      • All Loudspeaker Reviews
      • Passive Speaker
      • Active Analog Speaker
      • Active Digital Speaker
    • Digital
      • All Digital Reviews
      • CD Player
      • SPDIF DAC
      • USB DAC
      • Music Server
      • Network Player
      • Digital Recorder
      • Digital Interface
      • Audio Software
    • Turntable and Accessories
      • All Turntable and Accessories Reviews
      • Turntable
      • Tonearm
      • Phono Cartridge
      • Turntable Accessories
    • Cable
      • All Cable Reviews
      • Analog Interlink
      • Phono Interlink
      • Speaker Cable
      • Power Cable
      • Digital Cable
    • Accessories
      • All Accessories Reviews
      • Racks / Stands / Feet
      • Tuning / Tweaks
      • Power Connector
    • Industry Update
  • Insights
    • All Insights
    • Analog Insights
    • Cable Insights
    • Connector Insights
    • Digital Insights
    • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
    • Generic Insights
    • System Synergy Q&A
  • Specials
  • Show Reports
    • All Show Reports
    • Alkmaar Audio Show
    • Chattelin Audio Systems
    • Dutch Audio Event
    • Enosound
    • HifiDeluxe
    • HifiLive
    • Munich High End
    • XFi
  • Classics
    • All Classics
    • Analog Classics
    • Digital Classics
  • Links
  • About
    • About HFA
    • HFA Awards
    • Associated Equipment
    • Banners on HFA
    • HFA Analytics Data
    • HFA Audio Setup History
    • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
    • Sitemap
    • Contact
  • HFA Awards
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Amplifier
      • All Amplifier Reviews
      • Integrated Amplifier
      • Preamplifier
      • Power Amplifier
      • Phono Preamp
    • Loudspeaker
      • All Loudspeaker Reviews
      • Passive Speaker
      • Active Analog Speaker
      • Active Digital Speaker
    • Digital
      • All Digital Reviews
      • CD Player
      • SPDIF DAC
      • USB DAC
      • Music Server
      • Network Player
      • Digital Recorder
      • Digital Interface
      • Audio Software
    • Turntable and Accessories
      • All Turntable and Accessories Reviews
      • Turntable
      • Tonearm
      • Phono Cartridge
      • Turntable Accessories
    • Cable
      • All Cable Reviews
      • Analog Interlink
      • Phono Interlink
      • Speaker Cable
      • Power Cable
      • Digital Cable
    • Accessories
      • All Accessories Reviews
      • Racks / Stands / Feet
      • Tuning / Tweaks
      • Power Connector
    • Industry Update
  • Insights
    • All Insights
    • Analog Insights
    • Cable Insights
    • Connector Insights
    • Digital Insights
    • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
    • Generic Insights
    • System Synergy Q&A
  • Specials
  • Show Reports
    • All Show Reports
    • Alkmaar Audio Show
    • Chattelin Audio Systems
    • Dutch Audio Event
    • Enosound
    • HifiDeluxe
    • HifiLive
    • Munich High End
    • XFi
  • Classics
    • All Classics
    • Analog Classics
    • Digital Classics
  • Links
scroll down for more
Turntable Reviews

Thorens TD1601 vs AVID Diva II SP – Mini Review

Christiaan Punter 3 June 2021 5 Comments
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email

AVID turntable supplied by Hexagon Audio

Retail prices in the NL, including 21% VAT:
TD1601 – 2.999 euro
AVID Dive II SP – 4.100 euro (no tonearm)
AVID TA-3 tonearm – 550 euro

Just in the nick of time, on the evening before the day that the turntable would be picked up by Marco, I figured that it might be interesting to see how the AVID Diva II SP would compare to the Thorens TD1601. And at the same time, it will be nice to see how the AVID behaves in the secondary system, where the Thorens TD1601 is normally used.

Please note that this article will not be a full-on, in-depth review as I normally do but merely a quick comparison. Hence the Mini Review appendix.

Setup and Context

To keep this comparison simple, I will use the same cartridge for both players and a single arm on the Diva II SP. The Audio Technica AT33Sa Shibata-stylus low output MC cartridge works very well with all the tonearms that I have available and it will be swapped between the two players using the Acoustical Systems SMARTractor. The tonearm for the Diva II SP will be the entry-level AVID TA-3 (OEM Rega RB330).

The phono stage is the AVID Pulsare II (review forthcoming), set to 300 Ohms and the MID gain setting. The rest of the system consists of the Thorens TD1601 turntable, the Ayon Spirit III KT150 tube amp, and Xavian Perla Esclusiva speakers.

Price-wise, these two turntables are not real competitors. At 4.100 euro sans tonearm, the AVID is priced significantly higher than the 2.999-euro Thorens, which does come with a tonearm. Arguably a better comparative AVID turntable would have been the 2.550-euro standard Diva II (not SP) but that one’s not available. Of course, I could have also used the Ingenium but that’s an entry-level turntable intended for first-time vinyl enthusiasts and frankly, it is no match for the Thorens.

Listening

There is a certain synergy between Thorens turntables in general and my secondary system. The classic TD160 mkII, TD145 mkII, and TD125 mkII all worked well here and the TD1601 performs even better.

The TD1601 does particularly well to sound fluid and silky and super-refined while its inherent speed and agility make that the delivery is relaxed and highly engaging. The AT33Sa itself is highly refined and slightly sweet but it combines very well with the Thorens’ open and upbeat character, resulting in a gently smooth but agile, beautifully transparent, and well-detailed delivery. Coming from the classic Thorens turntables, the 1601’s bass is also great: fast and article but rather more full-bodied than before. I listened to a couple of tracks from different LPs swapped the AT33Sa to the Diva and played the same tracks.

Ok, so I thought the Thorens had surprisingly good bass, especially given my experience with the brand’s classic players that all sounded relatively lean. But as I already heard in the main system as part of the main AVID review, all the brand’s turntables are absolute bass champions. And indeed, in the secondary system as well, the Diva II SP has immensely robust and full-bodied bass. If the Thorens’ bass was already great, the Diva’s bass is absolutely magnificent. It has a super-impactful solidity that reminds me of the way that Wadia CD players sounded in the bottom end but with all the organic qualities that go along with the analog medium.

Another aspect that stands out with the Diva II SP is its fuller tonality and its very convincing and natural timbre. In comparison, the Thorens (with the AT33Sa at least) is leaner and relatively and subjectively less natural through the midrange. Although experience with the Dynavector DV20x2 cartridge confirmed that the AT33Sa plays a large part in this, there’s no denying that the Diva makes it sound more natural. Much of this stems from the turntable’s fuller bass and richer lower midrange but I’m confident that it’s also an inherent quality of the torsion-free AVID chassis in terms of purity and neutrality. Lastly, it is conceivable that the particularly lively (in some combinations forward to hard-sounding) AVID TA-3 / Rega tonearm further adds to this. Indeed, as I found, not all cartridges work synergistically with this tonearm but the relatively smooth AT33Sa certainly feels right at home.

So far, I’d say it’s a matter of taste and system synergy, but in terms of bass robustness and tonal fulness, the Diva is easily at an advantage. However, there’s another matter which again throws off the balance which is the treble behavior. Although the AT33Sa sounds relatively smooth with the Diva and TA-3 tonearm, the latter negatively influences the overall sound in terms of reduced extension, refinement, fluidity, and air. And in each of these areas, the Thorens has a clear advantage.

As mentioned, this article is only a Mini Review which means that I won’t dive too deeply into the various variables and there will be no overall conclusion. All I will say is that these two turntables clearly cater to different tastes and markets. For in-depth descriptions of the two turntables, please refer to their main reviews. But before signing off, I should mention two things.

First, it is abundantly clear that the AVID Diva’s performance is majorly restrained by the tonearm. Even though it performs admirably with the TA-3, the Diva simply deserves a much better tonearm. As I found during the main AVID review, swapping the TA-3 for the Audio Origami PU7 (12-gram effective mass version with Cardas 33ga internal wiring and super OFC external cable) did indeed make a world of difference. But at 3.100 euro, this would further offset a meaningful comparison with the Thorens.

Second, it’s worth noting that the Thorens TD1601 has a spring-suspended sub-chassis which the AVID Diva II SP lacks. And as became clear from the comparison between the Diva II SP and the Sequel during the main AVID review, the sub-chassis does indeed make a very large difference in terms of soundstage width, depth, and the overall flow in the music.

Ultimately, between the Diva II SP with TA-3 tonearm and the Thorens TD1601, my preference goes to the latter. However, given a better tonearm, that balance might tilt, but that will also further tilt the difference in price between the two players. The reality is that the Diva II SP is more of a high-end machine that deserves a higher-end tonearm and consequently comes at a higher-end price. If a better but still relatively modestly-priced tonearm comes along it will be interesting to see how the regular Diva II (not SP) performs.

 

Associated Equipment

External Links

Manufacturers: Thorens and AVID
Distributor for the Benelux: Lookenlisten and Hexagon Audio

Related Posts
Technics Grand Class SL-1200GR2, SL-1300G, and SL-1200G
Thorens TD1600 Turntable with TP 160 Tonearm
Denon DP-3000NE Direct-Drive Turntable with DL-103, DL-103R, and DL-A110 Cartridges
Bergmann Magne Air-Bearing turntable with DS Audio DS W3 Optical Cartridge
Bergmann presentation Euromast Rotterdam
AVID Ingenium, Diva II SP, and Sequel SP
Holbo Airbearing Turntable and Acoustical Systems Aiwon and Palladian MC cartridges
Thorens TD1601 Turntable
Audio Technica AVID AVIDHIFI Thorens
  • Share This:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email
Christiaan Punter Owner of Hifi-Advice.com

5 Comments

  1. Jon says:
    7 June 2021 at 23:42

    Thanks Christian very clear and well done comparison. I’m hopefully going to be in the market for a table next year Thorens is already on my radar but I’ll add Avid. My local dealer sells Thorens, Clearaudio, Audio Note, so those are all on my radar. Always fascinating to read about various arm/table/cartridge interactions, it really does seem like a bit of a black art to me!
    Cheers,
    Jon

    Reply
    1. Christiaan Punter says:
      8 June 2021 at 12:05

      Thanks Jon. Even though I am seeing more and more parallels in terms of what works and what does not, I agree that there are indeed aspects of tonearm and cartridge matching that still puzzle me! But it’s nothing that cannot be tackled with a healthy dose of curiosity and some experimentation:-). And, after all, that’s also a large part of the hobby. Or at least it is for me;-)

      Reply
  2. Chris Jordan says:
    14 August 2021 at 15:42

    Thanks for the great write up. I’m wondering if you have any thoughts on the VPI Prime 21 or VPI Prime Signature compared to the Diva II SP.

    Also, if I may ask, who makes the gorgeous white audio rack that is housing your stereo equipment in the pictures above? Thanks!

    Reply
    1. Christiaan Punter says:
      15 August 2021 at 15:40

      Hi Chris, I’ve never used a VPI turntable so I’m afraid I have nothing of substance to add in that respect. The rack is called the Modular Rack from the Organic Line by Artesania Audio.

      Reply
      1. Chris says:
        17 August 2021 at 00:19

        Thanks so much!

        Reply

Your comment Cancel reply

All feedback is welcome but I may not be able to respond to every comment. First-time comments need manual approval which may cause a slight delay. Avoid using links to prevent marking as spam.

 

Categories

  • Accessories Reviews
  • Active Analog Speakers Reviews
  • Active Digital Speakers Reviews
  • Alkmaar Audio Show
  • Amplifier Reviews
  • Analog Classics
  • Analog Insights
  • Analog Interlink Reviews
  • Analogy Records
  • Apogee Acoustics Company Special
  • Audio Software Reviews
  • Audiophile Insights
  • Cables Insights
  • CD Player Reviews
  • Chattelin Audio Systems
  • Connectors Insights
  • Digital Cable Reviews
  • Digital Classics
  • Digital Insights
  • Digital Interface Reviews
  • Digital Recorder Reviews
  • Digital Reviews
  • Dutch Audio Event
  • Enosound
  • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
  • Generic Insights
  • HFA Audio Setup History
  • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
  • HifiDeluxe
  • HifiLive
  • Industry Update
  • Integrated Amplifier Reviews
  • Marantz & Philips Classics
  • Munich High End
  • Music Server Reviews
  • Network Player Reviews
  • Passive Speakers Reviews
  • Phono Cartridge Reviews
  • Phono Interlink Reviews
  • Phono Preamp Reviews
  • Power Amplifier Reviews
  • Power Cable Reviews
  • Power Conditioning
  • Power Connector Reviews
  • Preamplifier Reviews
  • Racks / Stands / Feet Reviews
  • Rhapsody
  • Show Reports
  • SPDIF DAC Reviews
  • Speaker Cable Reviews
  • Specials
  • System Synergy Q&A
  • Tonearm Reviews
  • Tuning / Tweaks Reviews
  • Turntable Accessories Reviews
  • Turntable and Accessories Reviews
  • Turntable Reviews
  • Uncategorized
  • USB DAC Reviews
  • XFi

BRANDS

  • A&B Systems
  • A10 Audio
  • Aavik
  • Acapella
  • Accuphase
  • AcousticMatters
  • Acustica Applicata
  • Admire Audio
  • Aequo Audio
  • AG Lifter
  • Aidas
  • Akiko Audio
  • Analog Domain
  • Analogy Records
  • Analysis Audio
  • Analysis Plus
  • Ansuz
  • Anthem
  • Anti-Cables
  • Antipodes
  • APL
  • Apogee
  • Apogee Acoustics
  • Aqua
  • Arcam
  • Aries Cerat
  • Artesania
  • ASI
  • Astin Trew
  • atm audio
  • A Tube High Fidelity
  • Audeze
  • AudioAanZee
  • Audio Aero
  • Audio Club Premier
  • Audio GD
  • Audiolab
  • Audiolympic
  • Audiomeca
  • Audionote
  • Audio Note
  • Audio Origami
  • Audio Physic
  • AudioQuest
  • Audio Research
  • Audio Synthesis
  • Audio Technica
  • Auralic
  • Aurender
  • Aurum Cantus
  • Avalon
  • AvantGarde
  • AVID
  • AVIDHIFI
  • Ayon
  • Ayre Acoustics
  • B&W
  • Bals
  • Bang & Olufsen
  • Behringer
  • Belden
  • Benz
  • Bergmann
  • Black Rhodium
  • Boenicke Audio
  • Bowers & Wilkins
  • Bricasti
  • Bryston
  • Burmester
  • Børresen
  • CAD
  • Cardas
  • Care Orchestra
  • CAT
  • CEC
  • Chord Electronics
  • CH Precision
  • Clarisys Audio
  • Classé
  • Clearaudio
  • Concert Fidelity
  • Conrad Johnson
  • Consonance
  • COS
  • Curious Cables
  • D'Agostino
  • DAD
  • Dali
  • Daniël Hertz
  • Daudio
  • dCS
  • Degritter
  • Denafrips
  • Denon
  • Devialet
  • Devore
  • Diptyque
  • Doepke
  • Driade
  • DS Audio
  • Dynavector
  • Dynavox
  • E&T
  • EC-Designs
  • Echole
  • Elac
  • Electrocompaniet
  • Elijah Audio
  • EMAG
  • EMMLabs
  • Emotiva
  • EMU
  • Enosound
  • Ensemble
  • Esoteric
  • Estelon
  • Euphony
  • Exogal
  • Fadel Art
  • Fezz Audio
  • FIM Gold
  • Final
  • Final Touch Audio
  • Finite Elemente
  • FoilFlex
  • Franco Serblin
  • Furutech
  • Fusion Audio
  • Gauder Akustik
  • Genelec
  • Gigawatt
  • GiK
  • Goldmund
  • Graham Audio
  • Grandinote
  • Grimm Audio
  • Gryphon
  • Gustavson Audio
  • Halcro
  • Hanze Hifi
  • Harman/Kardon
  • Harmonic Resolution Systems
  • Harmonic Technology
  • Harmonix
  • Heaven's Gate
  • Hifi-Tuning
  • HiFi.nl
  • HifiMan
  • High Fidelity Cables
  • Hofa
  • Holo Audio
  • Home Audio Fidelity
  • HRS
  • IeGO
  • Ikigai
  • IMF
  • Isotek
  • Jadis
  • Jay's Audio
  • JCAT
  • Jeff Rowland
  • Jena Labs
  • JMF Audio
  • Jorma Audio
  • Jorma Design
  • Joseph Audio
  • JPLAY
  • JVC
  • Kemp
  • Kharma
  • Kimber
  • KingRex
  • Kinki Studio
  • KlinktBeter
  • Kora
  • Krell
  • Kroma Audio
  • Kupp
  • Laiv Audio
  • Lampizator
  • Lapp
  • LAST
  • Lector
  • Leema
  • Lejonklou
  • LessLoss
  • Line Magnetic
  • Linn
  • Logitech
  • LOK
  • Loudness War
  • Lumin
  • Luxman
  • M2Tech
  • Mad Scientist
  • Magico
  • Magnan
  • Magnepan
  • Mamba Audio
  • Manley Labs
  • Manunta
  • Marantz
  • Mark Levinson
  • Marten
  • Martin Logan
  • Master
  • Matrix
  • MBL
  • McIntosh
  • Melco
  • Melody
  • Meridian
  • Metrum Acoustics
  • Michell
  • MIT
  • MJ Acoustics
  • Modus Audio
  • Mogami
  • Mola-Mola
  • Monitor Audio
  • Monrio
  • Moon
  • Morel Hifi
  • Musical Fidelity
  • Mytek
  • Nagaoka
  • Naim
  • Naiu Laboratory
  • Nakamichi
  • NBS
  • Network Acoustics
  • Niels Setup
  • Nordost
  • NuPrime
  • Ohm Audio
  • Olive
  • Onkyo
  • Onzow
  • Origin Live
  • Ortofon
  • Oyaide
  • Panasonic
  • Paradigm
  • Parasound
  • Pass Labs
  • Philips
  • Pink Faun
  • Pioneer
  • Playback Designs
  • Precision Audio
  • PrimaLuna
  • Proceed
  • PS Audio
  • PUUR AVD
  • PUUR hifidelity
  • Pylon Audio
  • Qln
  • Qobuz
  • Quad
  • R.T.F.S.
  • RAAL Requisite
  • Raidho
  • Reference Sounds
  • Reference Tweaks
  • Rega
  • Rein Audio
  • REL
  • Resonator Stockholm
  • Revel
  • Ricable
  • Roon
  • RTFS
  • SAEQ
  • SAT
  • Schiit
  • Seawave Acoustic
  • Sennheiser
  • Shakti
  • Shuguang
  • Shunyata
  • Shure
  • Signal Projects
  • Silent Angel
  • Siltech
  • SME
  • SolidSteel
  • Solid Tech
  • Sonic Frontiers
  • Sonos
  • Sonus Faber
  • Sony
  • Sooloos
  • SOtM
  • Soulution
  • Sound Anchor
  • Sound Lab
  • Spectral
  • Spotify
  • Stack Audio
  • Stealth
  • Stillpoints
  • Straight Wire
  • SW1X Audio Design
  • Symo
  • Synergistic Research
  • Synology
  • Synthese
  • T+A
  • Taiko Audio
  • Tascam
  • Teac
  • TechDAS
  • Technics
  • The Chord Company
  • Thorens
  • Transparent Audio
  • Trends
  • Tung Sol
  • Unison Research
  • UpTone Audio
  • VAIC
  • van Damme
  • van den Hul
  • van Medevoort
  • Vermeer Audio
  • Vermouth Audio
  • Vibex
  • Vifa
  • Vincent
  • ViRa High End
  • Viva
  • Vivid Audio
  • VTL
  • Wadax
  • Wadia
  • Wattgate
  • Wattson
  • Way Cables
  • Weiss
  • Western Electric
  • WestminsterLab
  • Widealab
  • Wilson Audio
  • Wilson Benesch
  • Winyl
  • Wires 4 Music
  • Wireworld
  • Wolf von Langa
  • Wooden Bull
  • XACT
  • Xavian
  • xFyro
  • Xindak
  • XLO
  • Yamaha
  • Zanden
  • Zesto
  • ZYX

Visit HFA on Social Media

Instagram
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube

LEGAL

Privacy Policy

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. All rights reserved © 2021 - hifi-advice.com.
  • Contact
  • Home