• About
    • About HFA
    • HFA Awards
    • Associated Equipment
    • Banners on HFA
    • HFA Analytics Data
    • HFA Audio Setup History
    • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
    • Sitemap
    • Contact
  • HFA Awards
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Amplifier
      • All Amplifier Reviews
      • Integrated Amplifier
      • Preamplifier
      • Power Amplifier
      • Phono Preamp
    • Loudspeaker
      • All Loudspeaker Reviews
      • Passive Speaker
      • Active Analog Speaker
      • Active Digital Speaker
    • Digital
      • All Digital Reviews
      • CD Player
      • SPDIF DAC
      • USB DAC
      • Music Server
      • Network Player
      • Digital Recorder
      • Digital Interface
      • Audio Software
    • Turntable and Accessories
      • All Turntable and Accessories Reviews
      • Turntable
      • Tonearm
      • Phono Cartridge
      • Turntable Accessories
    • Cable
      • All Cable Reviews
      • Analog Interlink
      • Phono Interlink
      • Speaker Cable
      • Power Cable
      • Digital Cable
    • Accessories
      • All Accessories Reviews
      • Racks / Stands / Feet
      • Tuning / Tweaks
      • Power Connector
    • Industry Update
  • Insights
    • All Insights
    • Analog Insights
    • Cable Insights
    • Connector Insights
    • Digital Insights
    • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
    • Generic Insights
    • System Synergy Q&A
  • Specials
  • Show Reports
    • All Show Reports
    • Alkmaar Audio Show
    • Chattelin Audio Systems
    • Dutch Audio Event
    • Enosound
    • HifiDeluxe
    • HifiLive
    • Munich High End
    • XFi
  • Classics
    • All Classics
    • Analog Classics
    • Digital Classics
  • Links
  • About
    • About HFA
    • HFA Awards
    • Associated Equipment
    • Banners on HFA
    • HFA Analytics Data
    • HFA Audio Setup History
    • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
    • Sitemap
    • Contact
  • HFA Awards
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Amplifier
      • All Amplifier Reviews
      • Integrated Amplifier
      • Preamplifier
      • Power Amplifier
      • Phono Preamp
    • Loudspeaker
      • All Loudspeaker Reviews
      • Passive Speaker
      • Active Analog Speaker
      • Active Digital Speaker
    • Digital
      • All Digital Reviews
      • CD Player
      • SPDIF DAC
      • USB DAC
      • Music Server
      • Network Player
      • Digital Recorder
      • Digital Interface
      • Audio Software
    • Turntable and Accessories
      • All Turntable and Accessories Reviews
      • Turntable
      • Tonearm
      • Phono Cartridge
      • Turntable Accessories
    • Cable
      • All Cable Reviews
      • Analog Interlink
      • Phono Interlink
      • Speaker Cable
      • Power Cable
      • Digital Cable
    • Accessories
      • All Accessories Reviews
      • Racks / Stands / Feet
      • Tuning / Tweaks
      • Power Connector
    • Industry Update
  • Insights
    • All Insights
    • Analog Insights
    • Cable Insights
    • Connector Insights
    • Digital Insights
    • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
    • Generic Insights
    • System Synergy Q&A
  • Specials
  • Show Reports
    • All Show Reports
    • Alkmaar Audio Show
    • Chattelin Audio Systems
    • Dutch Audio Event
    • Enosound
    • HifiDeluxe
    • HifiLive
    • Munich High End
    • XFi
  • Classics
    • All Classics
    • Analog Classics
    • Digital Classics
  • Links
scroll down for more
Phono Cartridge Reviews

Audio Technica ATN150MLX and Shure M97xE MM Phono Cartridges

Christiaan Punter 25 February 2017 1 Comment
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email

Retail prices in the Netherlands:
Shure M97xE 119 euro
Audio Technica ATN150MLX 399 euro

shure_m97xm-img_0031_550pix

The Shure M97xE comes nicely packaged complete with all sorts of extras.

shure_m97xm-img_0032_750pix

It is not made to very tight tolerances but still looks very good for a 120 euro cartridge. A replacement stylus will cost 69 euro.

shure_m97xm-img_9929_550pix

The first sample I purchased had a severely misaligned stylus, as you can see above. I did not mount it but instead asked the retailer (Bax Shop) for a new sample. They promptly sent another, which was aligned correctly.

shure_m44g-img_0040_550pix

shure_m44g-img_0041_550pix

It seems to me that Shure has some issues with consistency and quality control for another Shure cartridge that I tried was the M44G, a DJ cartridge. For cartridges in this category, it is priced moderately at around 80 euro. This cartridge also had a misaligned cantilever, as you can see above. Here the needle tip leans toward one side. I tried it briefly but it sounded very thin, not at all what I was expecting from a DJ cartridge. Sure it would never provide true hifi sound, but I was inspired to buy this cartridge following a surprisingly positive experience using an old Stanton 505 cartridge. This oldie was low on detail retrieval but had biiiig bass and impressive dynamics and rocked as if its life depended on it. You could say that it had a loudness kind of sound, while the Shure M44G sounded almost opposite. But its misaligned stylus sure had a great deal to do with this.

audio-technica_atn150mlx-img_0173_550pix

This is the Audio Technica ATN150MLX MM cartridge with gold plated boron cantilever and nude shank micro-line stylus. That sure is a mouth full but no-nonsense: this really is a remarkable cartridge. I have owned it for a few years now and the only reason that I did not write about it earlier is that until now I was using even better MC cartridges, among which was also the Audio Technica AT33EV. Compared to that MC cartridge the Micro-line ATN150 provided even better tracking and less distortion playing old worn records than the AT33EV which “only” has a elliptical stylus, but otherwise sounded less sonorous and creamy-smooth than its MC cousin. As there were other MC cartridges that I used for a while, I never thought more of the ATN150 than it being “quite good for an MM”. However, now that I have listened to a whole range of MM cartridges, I am really finding out how good the ATN150 actually is. But then again, at 399 euro it better be good too. A replacement stylus for this cartridge will set you back a whopping 240 euro.

audio-technica_atn150mlx-img_0175_550pix

See that super-thin cantilever? You have to get the lighting just right, otherwise, it is near invisible.

audio-technica_atn150mlx-img_0174_550pix

audio-technica_atn150mlx-img_0177_550pix

A classy cartridge, the ATN150MLX

pioneer_pl-l1000-img_9961_550pix

This is the turntable used for comparisons: a Pioneer PL-L1000 linear tracker

sw1x_lpu_1_img_9962_550pix

Phono stage used is a SW1X LPU 1.

ortofon-lh2000-sw1x_lpu_1_img_0114_550pix

Here you can see the ATN150 mounted in an Ortofon LH 2000 headshell. This cartridge sounds very clean, a little lean, but with excellent detail retrieval and very clear and airy treble, without a hint of harshness. Tonally it is a little reminiscent of the Denon DL-304 MC cartridge, in as far as these can really be compared.

shure-m97xe-sw1x_lpu_1_img_0102_550pix

Here you can see the Shure M97 mounted in an Audio Technica HS10 headshell. As part of this review the cartridges were tested using both headshells, naturally while adjusting VTA and tracking force each time. Tracking force for both cartridges was the manufacturer’s recommended optimum weight of 1,25 grams.

Having used a couple of spherical-stylus cartridges I am finding that even though they can have great bass and dynamics, my used vinyl collection does not fare well with these regular shape styluses. Do note that many people use regular, affordable cartridges and many of those have spherical styluses. It makes sense that many of my second-hand worn records have been played with similar styluses and perhaps that is the main reason why elliptical, micro ridge and micro-line styluses retrieve cleaner signals from the grooves.

As explained above, the ATN150MLX has no trouble tracking even the worst vinyl that I have, and to be honest I would not expect less from a cartridge in its price class. The Shure M97xE is labeled by the brand as an “Audiophile” cartridge, and the reason for this is in part due to it employing a thin, higher compliance cantilever with an elliptical stylus. Naturally, I was not expecting true audiophile sound from a cartridge that costs only 120 euro, but imagine my surprise when I found that it tracks sublimely! Sure it does not track as well as the ATN150 and occasionally S’es lisp more loudly than they should, but old worn vinyl is tracked at least on the level of the much more expensive AT33EV!

Turntables-compared-550pix IMG_4219

AT33EV mounted on a Yamaha PX-2

But there’s more to the M97xE than good tracking: it actually sounds very refined, with clean, airy treble and bass that is not quite as articulate or as nimble as that produced by the ATN150MLX, but is more saturated and more powerful. Its midrange may be an opinion-divider in that it is a little recessed. It’s a little bit as though the loudness button has been engaged but not quite so because there’s still very good detail retrieval and liveliness in the midrange. In any event, its character fits well with the otherwise quite cool sounding Pioneer PL-L1000 turntable.

Conclusion

I don’t want to go as far as to announce a winner here, instead, I’d like to put in two separate honorable mentions for both cartridges, because they both perform admirably. The Audio Technica ATN150MLX is quite simply an excellent cartridge with superb tracking. It tracks equally well as a Benz ACE S with micro-ridge stylus, and I think that is really saying something. While I can’t be sure, I have a feeling that cartridges with super-fine styluses track superbly, but can also tend to sound a little thinner, less sonorous if you will, at least this has been the case with the Japanese cartridges that I tried such as Audio Technica and Denon. The Swiss ACE is a surprising deviation on this though, having nicely solid bass. The Shure on the other hand really surprised me with its smooth, sonorous and highly refined sound for so little money. Other cartridges will surely have trouble performing this well for 120 euro. However, it is important to note that the quality control may be an issue with this brand. Considering the cost/performance ratio however, this is understandable. Just make sure to buy from a trusted reseller and inspect the stylus prior to mounting it.


(ATN150mlx)

Associated Equipment

Read Also

Audio Technica HS10 and Ortofon LH 2000 Headshells compared

Related Posts
Thorens TAS 1500 and TAS 1600
Audio Technica AT-OC9XML and AT-OC9XSL MC Cartridges
Denon DP-3000NE Direct-Drive Turntable with DL-103, DL-103R, and DL-A110 Cartridges
AVIDHIFI BORON MC Cartridge
Onzow, DS Audio Dynavox, Winyl, and LAST Stylus Cleaning compared
ZYX R50 Bloom3
Audio Technica AT33Sa
Dynavector 10X5 MkII and DV20X2
Audio Technica Shure
  • Share This:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email
Christiaan Punter Owner of Hifi-Advice.com

1 Comments

  1. jim says:
    6 March 2017 at 23:43

    I recently switched to a AT150MLX from a older HOMC… and I have been very satisfied. It took about 10 hours to break in and may still be breaking in. Sounded shrill at first, but now sounds excellent. Track very well as you found.

    Reply

Your comment Cancel reply

All feedback is welcome but I may not be able to respond to every comment. First-time comments need manual approval which may cause a slight delay. Avoid using links to prevent marking as spam.

 

Categories

  • Accessories Reviews
  • Active Analog Speakers Reviews
  • Active Digital Speakers Reviews
  • Alkmaar Audio Show
  • Amplifier Reviews
  • Analog Classics
  • Analog Insights
  • Analog Interlink Reviews
  • Analogy Records
  • Apogee Acoustics Company Special
  • Audio Software Reviews
  • Audiophile Insights
  • Cables Insights
  • CD Player Reviews
  • Chattelin Audio Systems
  • Connectors Insights
  • Digital Cable Reviews
  • Digital Classics
  • Digital Insights
  • Digital Interface Reviews
  • Digital Recorder Reviews
  • Digital Reviews
  • Dutch Audio Event
  • Enosound
  • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
  • Generic Insights
  • HFA Audio Setup History
  • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
  • HifiDeluxe
  • HifiLive
  • Industry Update
  • Integrated Amplifier Reviews
  • Marantz & Philips Classics
  • Munich High End
  • Music Server Reviews
  • Network Player Reviews
  • Passive Speakers Reviews
  • Phono Cartridge Reviews
  • Phono Interlink Reviews
  • Phono Preamp Reviews
  • Power Amplifier Reviews
  • Power Cable Reviews
  • Power Conditioning
  • Power Connector Reviews
  • Preamplifier Reviews
  • Racks / Stands / Feet Reviews
  • Rhapsody
  • Show Reports
  • SPDIF DAC Reviews
  • Speaker Cable Reviews
  • Specials
  • System Synergy Q&A
  • Tonearm Reviews
  • Tuning / Tweaks Reviews
  • Turntable Accessories Reviews
  • Turntable and Accessories Reviews
  • Turntable Reviews
  • Uncategorized
  • USB DAC Reviews
  • XFi

BRANDS

  • A&B Systems
  • A10 Audio
  • Aavik
  • Acapella
  • Accuphase
  • AcousticMatters
  • Acustica Applicata
  • Admire Audio
  • Aequo Audio
  • AG Lifter
  • Aidas
  • Akiko Audio
  • Analog Domain
  • Analogy Records
  • Analysis Audio
  • Analysis Plus
  • Ansuz
  • Anthem
  • Anti-Cables
  • Antipodes
  • APL
  • Apogee
  • Apogee Acoustics
  • Aqua
  • Arcam
  • Aries Cerat
  • Artesania
  • ASI
  • Astin Trew
  • atm audio
  • A Tube High Fidelity
  • Audeze
  • AudioAanZee
  • Audio Aero
  • Audio Club Premier
  • Audio GD
  • Audiolab
  • Audiolympic
  • Audiomeca
  • Audio Note
  • Audionote
  • Audio Origami
  • Audio Physic
  • AudioQuest
  • Audio Research
  • Audio Synthesis
  • Audio Technica
  • Auralic
  • Aurender
  • Aurum Cantus
  • Avalon
  • AvantGarde
  • AVID
  • AVIDHIFI
  • Ayon
  • Ayre Acoustics
  • B&W
  • Bals
  • Bang & Olufsen
  • Behringer
  • Belden
  • Benz
  • Bergmann
  • Black Rhodium
  • Boenicke Audio
  • Bowers & Wilkins
  • Bricasti
  • Bryston
  • Burmester
  • Børresen
  • CAD
  • Cardas
  • Care Orchestra
  • CAT
  • CEC
  • Chord Electronics
  • CH Precision
  • Clarisys Audio
  • Classé
  • Clearaudio
  • Concert Fidelity
  • Conrad Johnson
  • Consonance
  • COS
  • Curious Cables
  • D'Agostino
  • DAD
  • Dali
  • Daniël Hertz
  • Daudio
  • dCS
  • Degritter
  • Denafrips
  • Denon
  • Devialet
  • Devore
  • Diptyque
  • Doepke
  • Driade
  • DS Audio
  • Dynavector
  • Dynavox
  • E&T
  • EC-Designs
  • Echole
  • Elac
  • Electrocompaniet
  • Elijah Audio
  • EMAG
  • EMMLabs
  • Emotiva
  • EMU
  • Enosound
  • Ensemble
  • Esoteric
  • Estelon
  • Euphony
  • Exogal
  • Fadel Art
  • Fezz Audio
  • FIM Gold
  • Final
  • Final Touch Audio
  • Finite Elemente
  • FoilFlex
  • Franco Serblin
  • Furutech
  • Fusion Audio
  • Gauder Akustik
  • Genelec
  • Gigawatt
  • GiK
  • Goldmund
  • Graham Audio
  • Grandinote
  • Grimm Audio
  • Gryphon
  • Gustavson Audio
  • Halcro
  • Hanze Hifi
  • Harman/Kardon
  • Harmonic Resolution Systems
  • Harmonic Technology
  • Harmonix
  • Heaven's Gate
  • Hifi-Tuning
  • HiFi.nl
  • HifiMan
  • High Fidelity Cables
  • Hofa
  • Holo Audio
  • Home Audio Fidelity
  • HRS
  • IeGO
  • Ikigai
  • IMF
  • Isotek
  • Jadis
  • Jay's Audio
  • JCAT
  • Jeff Rowland
  • Jena Labs
  • JMF Audio
  • Jorma Audio
  • Jorma Design
  • Joseph Audio
  • JPLAY
  • JVC
  • Kemp
  • Kharma
  • Kimber
  • KingRex
  • Kinki Studio
  • KlinktBeter
  • Kora
  • Krell
  • Kroma Audio
  • Kupp
  • Laiv Audio
  • Lampizator
  • Lapp
  • LAST
  • Lector
  • Leema
  • Lejonklou
  • LessLoss
  • Line Magnetic
  • Linn
  • Logitech
  • LOK
  • Loudness War
  • Lumin
  • Luxman
  • M2Tech
  • Mad Scientist
  • Magico
  • Magnan
  • Magnepan
  • Mamba Audio
  • Manley Labs
  • Manunta
  • Marantz
  • Mark Levinson
  • Marten
  • Martin Logan
  • Master
  • Matrix
  • MBL
  • McIntosh
  • Melco
  • Melody
  • Meridian
  • Metrum Acoustics
  • Michell
  • MIT
  • MJ Acoustics
  • Modus Audio
  • Mogami
  • Mola-Mola
  • Monitor Audio
  • Monrio
  • Moon
  • Morel Hifi
  • Musical Fidelity
  • Mytek
  • Nagaoka
  • Naim
  • Naiu Laboratory
  • Nakamichi
  • NBS
  • Network Acoustics
  • Niels Setup
  • Nordost
  • NuPrime
  • Ohm Audio
  • Olive
  • Onkyo
  • Onzow
  • Origin Live
  • Ortofon
  • Oyaide
  • Panasonic
  • Paradigm
  • Parasound
  • Pass Labs
  • Philips
  • Pink Faun
  • Pioneer
  • Playback Designs
  • Precision Audio
  • PrimaLuna
  • Proceed
  • PS Audio
  • PUUR AVD
  • PUUR hifidelity
  • Pylon Audio
  • Qln
  • Qobuz
  • Quad
  • R.T.F.S.
  • RAAL Requisite
  • Raidho
  • Reference Sounds
  • Reference Tweaks
  • Rega
  • Rein Audio
  • REL
  • Resonator Stockholm
  • Revel
  • Ricable
  • Roon
  • RTFS
  • SAEQ
  • SAT
  • Schiit
  • Seawave Acoustic
  • Sennheiser
  • Shakti
  • Shuguang
  • Shunyata
  • Shure
  • Signal Projects
  • Silent Angel
  • Siltech
  • SME
  • SolidSteel
  • Solid Tech
  • Sonic Frontiers
  • Sonos
  • Sonus Faber
  • Sony
  • Sooloos
  • SOtM
  • Soulution
  • Sound Anchor
  • Sound Lab
  • Spectral
  • Spotify
  • Stack Audio
  • Stealth
  • Stillpoints
  • Straight Wire
  • SW1X Audio Design
  • Symo
  • Synergistic Research
  • Synology
  • Synthese
  • T+A
  • Taiko Audio
  • Tascam
  • Teac
  • TechDAS
  • Technics
  • The Chord Company
  • Thorens
  • Transparent Audio
  • Trends
  • Tung Sol
  • Unison Research
  • UpTone Audio
  • VAIC
  • van Damme
  • van den Hul
  • van Medevoort
  • Vermeer Audio
  • Vermouth Audio
  • Vibex
  • Vifa
  • Vincent
  • ViRa High End
  • Viva
  • Vivid Audio
  • VTL
  • Wadax
  • Wadia
  • Wattgate
  • Wattson
  • Way Cables
  • Weiss
  • Western Electric
  • WestminsterLab
  • Widealab
  • Wilson Audio
  • Wilson Benesch
  • Winyl
  • Wires 4 Music
  • Wireworld
  • Wolf von Langa
  • Wooden Bull
  • XACT
  • Xavian
  • xFyro
  • Xindak
  • XLO
  • Yamaha
  • Zanden
  • Zesto
  • ZYX

Visit HFA on Social Media

Instagram
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube

LEGAL

Privacy Policy

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. All rights reserved © 2021 - hifi-advice.com.
  • Contact
  • Home