• About
    • About HFA
    • HFA Awards
    • Associated Equipment
    • Banners on HFA
    • HFA Analytics Data
    • HFA Audio Setup History
    • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
    • Sitemap
    • Contact
  • HFA Awards
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Amplifier
      • All Amplifier Reviews
      • Integrated Amplifier
      • Preamplifier
      • Power Amplifier
      • Phono Preamp
    • Loudspeaker
      • All Loudspeaker Reviews
      • Passive Speaker
      • Active Analog Speaker
      • Active Digital Speaker
    • Digital
      • All Digital Reviews
      • CD Player
      • SPDIF DAC
      • USB DAC
      • Music Server
      • Network Player
      • Digital Recorder
      • Digital Interface
      • Audio Software
    • Turntable and Accessories
      • All Turntable and Accessories Reviews
      • Turntable
      • Tonearm
      • Phono Cartridge
      • Turntable Accessories
    • Cable
      • All Cable Reviews
      • Analog Interlink
      • Phono Interlink
      • Speaker Cable
      • Power Cable
      • Digital Cable
    • Accessories
      • All Accessories Reviews
      • Racks / Stands / Feet
      • Tuning / Tweaks
      • Power Connector
    • Industry Update
  • Insights
    • All Insights
    • Analog Insights
    • Cable Insights
    • Connector Insights
    • Digital Insights
    • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
    • Generic Insights
    • System Synergy Q&A
  • Specials
  • Show Reports
    • All Show Reports
    • Alkmaar Audio Show
    • Chattelin Audio Systems
    • Dutch Audio Event
    • Enosound
    • HifiDeluxe
    • HifiLive
    • Munich High End
    • XFi
  • Classics
    • All Classics
    • Analog Classics
    • Digital Classics
  • Links
  • About
    • About HFA
    • HFA Awards
    • Associated Equipment
    • Banners on HFA
    • HFA Analytics Data
    • HFA Audio Setup History
    • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
    • Sitemap
    • Contact
  • HFA Awards
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Amplifier
      • All Amplifier Reviews
      • Integrated Amplifier
      • Preamplifier
      • Power Amplifier
      • Phono Preamp
    • Loudspeaker
      • All Loudspeaker Reviews
      • Passive Speaker
      • Active Analog Speaker
      • Active Digital Speaker
    • Digital
      • All Digital Reviews
      • CD Player
      • SPDIF DAC
      • USB DAC
      • Music Server
      • Network Player
      • Digital Recorder
      • Digital Interface
      • Audio Software
    • Turntable and Accessories
      • All Turntable and Accessories Reviews
      • Turntable
      • Tonearm
      • Phono Cartridge
      • Turntable Accessories
    • Cable
      • All Cable Reviews
      • Analog Interlink
      • Phono Interlink
      • Speaker Cable
      • Power Cable
      • Digital Cable
    • Accessories
      • All Accessories Reviews
      • Racks / Stands / Feet
      • Tuning / Tweaks
      • Power Connector
    • Industry Update
  • Insights
    • All Insights
    • Analog Insights
    • Cable Insights
    • Connector Insights
    • Digital Insights
    • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
    • Generic Insights
    • System Synergy Q&A
  • Specials
  • Show Reports
    • All Show Reports
    • Alkmaar Audio Show
    • Chattelin Audio Systems
    • Dutch Audio Event
    • Enosound
    • HifiDeluxe
    • HifiLive
    • Munich High End
    • XFi
  • Classics
    • All Classics
    • Analog Classics
    • Digital Classics
  • Links
scroll down for more
Digital Insights

“Digital” Switching Class D or Class T amplifiers

Christiaan Punter 28 December 2016 5 Comments
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email

So-called “digital” amps aren’t digital at all

Bang and Olufsen had this module that sounded amazing. Soon thereafter Jeff Rowland more or less started the hype with their beautiful miniature model 201 monoblocks that had these so-called ICE-Power modules inside and soon thereafter PS Audio solidified the trend with a proprietary amp. But of course, there were others who made class D amps before Rowland did, like Tact, now Lyngdorf Audio and Sharp. The Tact products were beautiful but somehow never reached a big market and remained broadly invisible to the larger public for a long time. And there were do-it-yourself kits a long time before that. Most people know that class D is more efficient than class A or even class A/B and has huge power reserves while remaining cool to the touch. There are now class D amps from B&O (Jeff Rowland), Hypex, PS Audio, Tact (now Lyngdorf Audio) Bel Canto and many others. Class D amplifiers are now even incorporated in home cinema receivers.

rowland-model-201-new_550pix

Above: Jeff Rowland Model 201

Class D or Class T

According to Wikipedia, “A Class T amplifier is an audio amplifier IC design. Rather than being a separate “class” of amplifier, Class T is a registered trademark for Tripath’s amplifier technologies. The control signals in Class T amplifiers may be computed using digital signal processing or fully analog techniques.” The page then goes into detail but I’ll not quote all that here. So, it seems that most switching amps are class D, some are erroneously called class T and some really are class T.

rowland-model-201-1_550pix

Above: Jeff Rowland Model 201 inside

But what about the working principle behind it?

There are good reasons why you could call class D amplifiers analog and not digital.

A device delivering power to a speaker is by definition analog. The analog input signal is modulated but is not digital. There are no A-D and D-A converters. Analog in, analog out, analog. Isn’t it?

Class D amps are called switching amps because they’re either completely on or off. There’s no in-between. The output is switched at a very high frequency, modulated to the music. A class D amp delivers either all of the current available from its power supply, or none. The voltage doesn’t change, but the period for which it is on, does. The longer a pulse, the louder its equivalent volume in the resulting music. This is called Pulse Width Modulation, which is also used in digital. Which explains why you could mistakenly call Class D amplifiers digital. Class D can also use Sigma/Delta modulation, but I’ll let that pass for now. In Class D the music signal is modulated on a very high carrier frequency that can be easily filtered out, together with the necessary smoothing of the chopped signal to recreate a nice gentle waveform.

This method is very different from regular class A/B, where there is (explained in simplified form) a power transistor that is fed by a low voltage signal on one leg, a huge power reserve on the second leg and the speaker on the third leg. The input signal is merely amplified. The transistor is continually varying its output voltage.

ps-audio-hca-2-hybrid-class-a-2_432pix

Above: PS Audio HCA-2

Of course, there are exceptions to the rule. Sharp for example has made an integrated amplifier that has digital inputs, and digital volume control and Tact, now Lyngdorf Audio, also has a completely digital amplifier, although the speakers are fed an analog signal of course. Lastly, the B&O modules are also available with digital inputs. But these still operate in an analog fashion.

tact-audio-millennium-mk3-digital-amplifier_550pix

Above: TacT Audio Millennium mk3

tact-tda-2200-front_550pix

Above: TacT TDA2200

Efficiency

Here are some indications regarding efficiency. The numbers are mere indicative, not absolute, but you’ll get the picture.

Class A = 25% efficient.
Class AB = 50% efficient
Class D = above 90% efficient

Class A always consumes the same amount of power and to output 40 watts into a hungry speaker, it would consume about 100 watts from the mains. Because class D draws less current from the mains, a much smaller transformer can be used and a lot less heat is produced.

tact-audio-millennium-mk3-digital-amplifier-intern-3_550pix

TacT Audio Millennium mk3 inside

tact-audio-millennium-mk3-digital-amplifier-intern-1_550pix

Sound Quality

The class D amps I’ve heard so far (Jeff Rowland 201, 501 and Hypex, and some other brands) sound less powerful than the rating suggests and they can lack bass, compared to many class AB amps. The bass sure is tight, deep and fast but lacks some meat on the bones. It is simply not as gutsy and has less slam than regular big transistor amps. It is the nature of Class D to sound very open, agile, fast and well-detailed and at the same time they can sound very smooth, with no apparent grain at all. The good news is that class D can much easier accomplish very good sound at low cost than class AB. For me, regular transistor amps are still the way to go but it looks like Class D will have a bright future. Maybe our governments will even go as far as to forbid production of power-hungry amplifiers. If and when that happens, I hope that manufacturers have found a way to make Class D sound more meaty and gutsy. Bryston power from a package smaller than a pack of cigarettes. Wouldn’t that be great?

Update 7 December 2009 – Audio Physic Mono power amps

audio physic mono in setup IMG_2202_550pix

The other day I listened to the Audio Physic Mono digital poweramps. Well, digital, they’re Class ND switching amps, which is a technique I know little about so whether they are in fact digital I will leave in the middle… The point is: these amps do not have the lean sound that I heard in the other switching amps. The Audio Physics sound, well, physical. They have a full color pallete, with great bass on par with my Rowlands. Also detailing is pretty good and they even have a warm and inviting character. The only things missing are the refined subtlety and air in the treble that the Rowlands are capable of. But I wanted to mention this nevertheless, since one or my greatest beefs with switching amps seems to have been overcome. Admittedly by amps made in 2004 that were 15000 euro the time. We may see more developments here and probably ultimately the demise of class A/B. Which is fine by me, as long as the resultant amps equal or maybe even better traditional designs.

Update 2011

In 2011 I conducted a comparison of 3 class D amplifiers and 1 class T amp.
Read the review here

Conclusion

There’s nothing to conclude just yet I’m afraid… switching amplifier technology is still very much being refined every day. So far I still tend to favour class A/B but I am leaning over ever more to the new world. I have no doubt that pretty soon the debate over the classes will be reduced to a discussion over taste, not absolute quality.

Update December 2017

Now having heard the NuPrime ST-10 and MolaMola Kaluga class D amplifiers (reviewed here briefly as part of another review), I must conclude that the future is here now. No longer does Class D have to stand in the shade of Class A or A/B designs. Sure, the delivery is different than the stereotypical class-A or class-A/B amp, but pure, dynamic, refined and since hearing the aforementioned designs, now also timbrally convincing (especially the NuPrime) and with superb resolution and treble performance (Mola-Mola).

Read Also

Wadia 151 compared to Jeff Rowland 102, Trends TA_10.2 and OEM ICE module
Wadia 151 inside pics

Related Posts
Digital Cables compared – USB and Ethernet
The Difference Between Instrumental and Speaker Cables (Guest Review)
Computer Audio part 6 – Perspective
Bliss
Music Server Placement and the influence of Network Cable and Switches
Kernel Streaming for Winamp 5
CD Ripping
WAV and Tagging
  • Share This:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email
Christiaan Punter Owner of Hifi-Advice.com

5 Comments

  1. Michael Fanning says:
    23 March 2019 at 14:52

    Witness the Lyndgorf TDAI-3400 and its precursor the TDAI-2170. I’d say the future is here…

    Reply
  2. James says:
    24 August 2020 at 05:55

    Redjoejazz472005@yahoo.com
    I have a class D amp, 150 watts each channel into 8 ohms. What’s lacking is the beef/ slam in the bass, otherwise the overall sound is tight and clear-clean., matching preamp also. I currently switch back to my adcom Gfa555 power amp but use the preamp of the matching class d set.

    Reply
    1. Christiaan Punter says:
      24 August 2020 at 08:57

      I fully understand what you’re saying and I have often felt the same way. However, over time, my opinion on the matter, and my respect for Class-D, has changed. Granted, Class-D’s tightness can give the impression of having little bass or indeed lacking slam or body. But over the years, the better and more transparent my system got, the more I started to notice how subjectively nice-sounding “big balls bass” is often slower, rounder and thicker than it should be. Now, there’s nothing wrong with that of course, you should use whichever makes you happy and/or gives you the illusion of realism. Big old Krells, Any Bryston and, to some extent, even Soulution amps fall into this camp. CH Precision, however, sounds much more like typical Class-D in the bass (not in the midrange of treble, fortunately) which further substantiates my feeling that Class-D bass is likely much closer to perfection than it may lead one to believe. The thing is that often our systems are tuned to preceding components, complete with all their pluses and minuses. When dropping a much cleaner-sounding amp in such a system, the balance is off. This requires a re-thinking of the associated components, the cabling and the placement of the setup. In conclusion, I’m not saying that Class-D is perfect, it really is not. But I do think that typical Class-D bass is likely closer to the truth than what many Class A or Class A/B amps can achieve. Then, of course, not everyone wants the truth and it remains a personal matter:-)

      Reply
  3. JohnIL says:
    24 November 2021 at 18:38

    I bought one of these cheap Lepai class T amps for a desktop speaker system for my PC. Hooked to a pair of Polk T15 book shelf speakers. The amp produces pleasing sound but certainly leaves a lot of questions about how good of quality the design is even though there is no doubt it’s really an efficient design. I think it’s better suited to a multi channel multi media system than a musically oriented system.

    Reply
    1. Iulius says:
      4 February 2025 at 21:38

      Change the audio cables. I have a similar setup on my computer with Lepay and Onkyo D-N10BX speakers and after changing the cables to professional 10 AWG cables and using shielded cable for the input, the sound quality improved a lot and I personally think it sounds as good as a class AB amplifier.

      Reply

Your comment Cancel reply

All feedback is welcome but I may not be able to respond to every comment. First-time comments need manual approval which may cause a slight delay. Avoid using links to prevent marking as spam.

 

Categories

  • Accessories Reviews
  • Active Analog Speakers Reviews
  • Active Digital Speakers Reviews
  • Alkmaar Audio Show
  • Amplifier Reviews
  • Analog Classics
  • Analog Insights
  • Analog Interlink Reviews
  • Analogy Records
  • Apogee Acoustics Company Special
  • Audio Software Reviews
  • Audiophile Insights
  • Cables Insights
  • CD Player Reviews
  • Chattelin Audio Systems
  • Connectors Insights
  • Digital Cable Reviews
  • Digital Classics
  • Digital Insights
  • Digital Interface Reviews
  • Digital Recorder Reviews
  • Digital Reviews
  • Dutch Audio Event
  • Enosound
  • Extensionblocks / Filters Insights
  • Generic Insights
  • HFA Audio Setup History
  • HFA Audio Setup Snapshots
  • HifiDeluxe
  • HifiLive
  • Industry Update
  • Integrated Amplifier Reviews
  • Marantz & Philips Classics
  • Munich High End
  • Music Server Reviews
  • Network Player Reviews
  • Passive Speakers Reviews
  • Phono Cartridge Reviews
  • Phono Interlink Reviews
  • Phono Preamp Reviews
  • Power Amplifier Reviews
  • Power Cable Reviews
  • Power Conditioning
  • Power Connector Reviews
  • Preamplifier Reviews
  • Racks / Stands / Feet Reviews
  • Rhapsody
  • Show Reports
  • SPDIF DAC Reviews
  • Speaker Cable Reviews
  • Specials
  • System Synergy Q&A
  • Tonearm Reviews
  • Tuning / Tweaks Reviews
  • Turntable Accessories Reviews
  • Turntable and Accessories Reviews
  • Turntable Reviews
  • Uncategorized
  • USB DAC Reviews
  • XFi

BRANDS

  • A&B Systems
  • A10 Audio
  • Aavik
  • Acapella
  • Accuphase
  • AcousticMatters
  • Acustica Applicata
  • Admire Audio
  • Aequo Audio
  • AG Lifter
  • Aidas
  • Akiko Audio
  • Analog Domain
  • Analogy Records
  • Analysis Audio
  • Analysis Plus
  • Ansuz
  • Anthem
  • Anti-Cables
  • Antipodes
  • APL
  • Apogee
  • Apogee Acoustics
  • Aqua
  • Arcam
  • Aries Cerat
  • Artesania
  • ASI
  • Astin Trew
  • atm audio
  • A Tube High Fidelity
  • Audeze
  • AudioAanZee
  • Audio Aero
  • Audio Club Premier
  • Audio GD
  • Audiolab
  • Audiolympic
  • Audiomeca
  • Audio Note
  • Audionote
  • Audio Origami
  • Audio Physic
  • AudioQuest
  • Audio Research
  • Audio Synthesis
  • Audio Technica
  • Auralic
  • Aurender
  • Aurum Cantus
  • Avalon
  • AvantGarde
  • AVID
  • AVIDHIFI
  • Ayon
  • Ayre Acoustics
  • B&W
  • Bals
  • Bang & Olufsen
  • Behringer
  • Belden
  • Benz
  • Bergmann
  • Black Rhodium
  • Boenicke Audio
  • Bowers & Wilkins
  • Bricasti
  • Bryston
  • Burmester
  • Børresen
  • CAD
  • Cardas
  • Care Orchestra
  • CAT
  • CEC
  • Chord Electronics
  • CH Precision
  • Clarisys Audio
  • Classé
  • Clearaudio
  • Concert Fidelity
  • Conrad Johnson
  • Consonance
  • COS
  • Curious Cables
  • D'Agostino
  • DAD
  • Dali
  • Daniël Hertz
  • Daudio
  • dCS
  • Degritter
  • Denafrips
  • Denon
  • Devialet
  • Devore
  • Diptyque
  • Doepke
  • Driade
  • DS Audio
  • Dynavector
  • Dynavox
  • E&T
  • EC-Designs
  • Echole
  • Elac
  • Electrocompaniet
  • Elijah Audio
  • EMAG
  • EMMLabs
  • Emotiva
  • EMU
  • Enosound
  • Ensemble
  • Esoteric
  • Estelon
  • Euphony
  • Exogal
  • Fadel Art
  • Fezz Audio
  • FIM Gold
  • Final
  • Final Touch Audio
  • Finite Elemente
  • FoilFlex
  • Franco Serblin
  • Furutech
  • Fusion Audio
  • Gauder Akustik
  • Genelec
  • Gigawatt
  • GiK
  • Goldmund
  • Graham Audio
  • Grandinote
  • Grimm Audio
  • Gryphon
  • Gustavson Audio
  • Halcro
  • Hanze Hifi
  • Harman/Kardon
  • Harmonic Resolution Systems
  • Harmonic Technology
  • Harmonix
  • Heaven's Gate
  • Hifi-Tuning
  • HiFi.nl
  • HifiMan
  • High Fidelity Cables
  • Hofa
  • Holo Audio
  • Home Audio Fidelity
  • HRS
  • IeGO
  • Ikigai
  • IMF
  • Isotek
  • Jadis
  • Jay's Audio
  • JCAT
  • Jeff Rowland
  • Jena Labs
  • JMF Audio
  • Jorma Audio
  • Jorma Design
  • Joseph Audio
  • JPLAY
  • JVC
  • Kemp
  • Kharma
  • Kimber
  • KingRex
  • Kinki Studio
  • KlinktBeter
  • Kora
  • Krell
  • Kroma Audio
  • Kupp
  • Laiv Audio
  • Lampizator
  • Lapp
  • LAST
  • Lector
  • Leema
  • Lejonklou
  • LessLoss
  • Line Magnetic
  • Linn
  • Logitech
  • LOK
  • Loudness War
  • Lumin
  • Luxman
  • M2Tech
  • Mad Scientist
  • Magico
  • Magnan
  • Magnepan
  • Mamba Audio
  • Manley Labs
  • Manunta
  • Marantz
  • Mark Levinson
  • Marten
  • Martin Logan
  • Master
  • Matrix
  • MBL
  • McIntosh
  • Melco
  • Melody
  • Meridian
  • Metrum Acoustics
  • Michell
  • MIT
  • MJ Acoustics
  • Modus Audio
  • Mogami
  • Mola-Mola
  • Monitor Audio
  • Monrio
  • Moon
  • Morel Hifi
  • Musical Fidelity
  • Mytek
  • Nagaoka
  • Naim
  • Naiu Laboratory
  • Nakamichi
  • NBS
  • Network Acoustics
  • Niels Setup
  • Nordost
  • NuPrime
  • Ohm Audio
  • Olive
  • Onkyo
  • Onzow
  • Origin Live
  • Ortofon
  • Oyaide
  • Panasonic
  • Paradigm
  • Parasound
  • Pass Labs
  • Philips
  • Pink Faun
  • Pioneer
  • Playback Designs
  • Precision Audio
  • PrimaLuna
  • Proceed
  • PS Audio
  • PUUR AVD
  • PUUR hifidelity
  • Pylon Audio
  • Qln
  • Qobuz
  • Quad
  • R.T.F.S.
  • RAAL Requisite
  • Raidho
  • Reference Sounds
  • Reference Tweaks
  • Rega
  • Rein Audio
  • REL
  • Resonator Stockholm
  • Revel
  • Ricable
  • Roon
  • RTFS
  • SAEQ
  • SAT
  • Schiit
  • Seawave Acoustic
  • Sennheiser
  • Shakti
  • Shuguang
  • Shunyata
  • Shure
  • Signal Projects
  • Silent Angel
  • Siltech
  • SME
  • SolidSteel
  • Solid Tech
  • Sonic Frontiers
  • Sonos
  • Sonus Faber
  • Sony
  • Sooloos
  • SOtM
  • Soulution
  • Sound Anchor
  • Sound Lab
  • Spectral
  • Spotify
  • Stack Audio
  • Stealth
  • Stillpoints
  • Straight Wire
  • SW1X Audio Design
  • Symo
  • Synergistic Research
  • Synology
  • Synthese
  • T+A
  • Taiko Audio
  • Tascam
  • Teac
  • TechDAS
  • Technics
  • The Chord Company
  • Thorens
  • Transparent Audio
  • Trends
  • Tung Sol
  • Unison Research
  • UpTone Audio
  • VAIC
  • van Damme
  • van den Hul
  • van Medevoort
  • Vermeer Audio
  • Vermouth Audio
  • Vibex
  • Vifa
  • Vincent
  • ViRa High End
  • Viva
  • Vivid Audio
  • VTL
  • Wadax
  • Wadia
  • Wattgate
  • Wattson
  • Way Cables
  • Weiss
  • Western Electric
  • WestminsterLab
  • Widealab
  • Wilson Audio
  • Wilson Benesch
  • Winyl
  • Wires 4 Music
  • Wireworld
  • Wolf von Langa
  • Wooden Bull
  • XACT
  • Xavian
  • xFyro
  • Xindak
  • XLO
  • Yamaha
  • Zanden
  • Zesto
  • ZYX

Visit HFA on Social Media

Instagram
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube

LEGAL

Privacy Policy

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. All rights reserved © 2021 - hifi-advice.com.
  • Contact
  • Home